Search This Blog

Friday, November 6, 2020

The Class System is KO for UK - time for debates

 


 

TASK 1.  Ready to debate:  

  •   a)   So, education is better than wealth! ... LINK  
  •   
  •  b)  Should we have one global language?  .... link



 1.  History Boys - Mr Bennet masterpiece (2006) 

                           

PLOT:  The story concerns a group of eighteen-year-old working-class boys who have returned to high school for an extra semester in order to study for an entrance examination and interview for Oxford University.  Bennet's language clearly cuts differences in class and accent!

   

RICH DEBATE. 02  

The education conundrum at its heart poses a question with universal meaning: 

    • Does the kind of education that gains students a place in a country's most prestigious universities come at a cost of never learning how to nurture the mind's garden for a fully realized life? - review link



Most American audience members would certainly have picked up that the play is set in England but not have been able to locate the play within a region of England. 

 

For example, most British accents would pronounce the first syllable of the word “tuna” as /tch/ - a sound that to an American ear sounds more like the word cheese.


  FILM- Trailer   (2 min) 

Boys learn their lesson

The serious teacher link


 Three teachers:  Hector, Irwin and Mrs Lintott, the only female in the cast. 

                  Three quotes:

1/ Mrs Lintott:  
    
            "The chief enemy of culture in any school is the headmaster"

Shall I tell you what is wrong with Hector as a teacher? It isn't that he doesn't produce results. He does. But they are unpredictable and unquantifiable and in the current educational climate that is no use.
He may very well be doing his job, but there is no method I know of that       enables me to assess the job that he is doing. 
          There is inspiration, certainly, but how do I quantify that?   (page 70)  

3 /      Hector: 

                        May I make a silly suggestion Why can they not all just tell the truth

             Irwin

               'It's worth trying, provided, of course,

                         you can make it seem like you're telling the truth'

 



  2.   Kate Fox .    The Class System is Static in the UK

"Who controls the past controls the future: 
who controls the present controls the past"
-                       Orwell, 1984

 


Several statements from Kate Fox 
on the English class delegitimasion   (till 05:30)

      1.-   The history lessons we didn't learnt!

  Top politicians Before Boris Johnson (BoJo)

  • Tony Blair  1990s
    John Major 1987-88
    Thatcher  1980s
    1959 Harold Macmillan 


01:17  Any fool could see that the class system is

very obviously still alive and kicking

so it was a bit of *a slam dunk pretty

       (*=  to win something very easily, or to do sth very successfully)

01:25 but at the time Tony Blair was confidently declaring the class war is over 

and John Prescott was telling us 'the middle class had won'

01:37 at least he said " we're all middle class now"

01:39 so I assume that means 'the middle class' had won.

 but ten years before that - roughly -

01:44 we had John Major promising us 

a classless society in about ten years and

01:52  there were debates when Tony Blair was talking

01:55 debates when John Major said it ten years before

 that we had Thatcher, telling us that

"Marks and Spencer had triumphed over  Marx and Engels

which I think was another way of saying

  'the class war is over, the middle class has won'

 you can rewind back as far as you like

 almost it's set in 1959 Harold Macmillan again very confidently 

02:21  declared that 'the class war is obsolete'...


  2.-   The class syst

02:48  education policy in an attempt to increase social mobility because

 that worked so well the last times we tried it

so, they give their visionary rose-tinted speeches

the class war is over etc. 

we have debates. Nothing changes.


  3.-   The class system 

I'm not arguing that the class system is dirty

I'm just saying that these are the kind of things

03:35 that have been said by politicians

not that they could or could have done better

or should have done better

I'm actually saying it possibly impossible for them to do better,



 4.- Dinner -lunch choices bit

about five, six people maybe 

             04:55 little tiny tiny glimmering of social mobility

         




Sociologist Kate Fox , as the third speaker in Parliament (of six) in the debate.

                    TASK 2. Listen 2 Wr  -8 min      video  11:42 min 


                         https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a23sbePXLP8

  • ·         She's really in the lion's den with this topic. The condescending stares, taciturn reception and weak applause tell volumes about the prejudiced and self-important attitude of these post-pubescent upstarts, virtually all of whom were born with a silver spoon in their mouths. 


some of the comments here confirm the loathsome arrogance exuded by her well-off audience.
  • .

No comments: